Choosing Between an Oxygen Concentrator and an Oxygen Tank: What’s Best for You?
For individuals with respiratory conditions, having a reliable oxygen source is crucial. But should you choose an oxygen concentrator or an oxygen tank? Understanding the differences, benefits, and limitations of each can help you make the best decision for your needs.
An oxygen concentrator is a device that pulls in air, removes nitrogen, and delivers purified oxygen to the user. Unlike oxygen tanks, it does not need refilling, as it continuously generates oxygen.
Available sizes:
✅ No need for refilling – cost-effective in the long run
✅ Ideal for home use – provides continuous oxygen
✅ Safer – no risk of leaks or explosions
❌ Requires electricity – not suitable during power outages
❌ Less portable – may not be ideal for outdoor use
❌ Limited oxygen purity compared to tanks
An oxygen tank is a pre-filled cylinder containing compressed oxygen. It provides immediate, high-purity oxygen but requires refilling at an oxygen gas station.
✅ Portable – can be used anywhere, even outside
✅ Provides high-purity oxygen
✅ Works without electricity – ideal for emergencies
❌ Needs regular refilling – additional cost and effort
❌ Risk of running out of oxygen unexpectedly
❌ Heavy – may not be convenient for everyday use
| Volume (m³) | Size | 1 LPM (hours) | 2 LPM (hours) | 3 LPM (hours) | 4 LPM (hours) | 5 LPM (hours) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.5 m³ | Size D (2.8L) | 8.33 hours | 4.17 hours | 2.78 hours | 2.08 hours | 1.67 hours |
| 0.7 m³ | Size E (4.6L) | 11.67 hours | 5.83 hours | 3.89 hours | 2.92 hours | 2.33 hours |
| 1.4 m³ | Size F (10L) | 23.33 hours | 11.67 hours | 7.78 hours | 5.83 hours | 4.67 hours |
| Consideration | Oxygen Concentrator | Oxygen Tank |
|---|---|---|
| For home use | ✅ Cost-effective, continuous supply | ❌ Requires frequent refills |
| For mobility/outdoor use | ❌ Requires power, less portable | ✅ Easy to carry for short trips |
| For emergency backup | ❌ Stops working during power outages | ✅ Reliable when power is out |
| For long-term therapy | ✅ No need to refill | ❌ May require multiple tanks |
| Oxygen Concentrator | Oxygen Tank |
|---|---|
| Purity: 88 - 95% | Purity: Minimum 99.5% |
| Pressure: 7.5 to 15 psig | Pressure: Preset 50 to 80 psig |
✔ Store oxygen tanks in a well-ventilated area and upright position
✔ Turn off oxygen when not in use
✔ Monitor oxygen levels and schedule refills in advance
✔ Keep oxygen concentrators at least 6 inches away from walls or curtains
✔ Consider having a backup power source for concentrators
✘ Do not smoke while using oxygen
✘ Do not use petroleum-based products (like Vaseline)
✘ Do not store oxygen tanks in enclosed spaces (closets, car trunks)
✘ Do not use extension cords for concentrators
✘ Do not adjust the oxygen flow without consulting your doctor
Choosing between an oxygen concentrator and an oxygen tank depends on your lifestyle, mobility, and medical needs. If you require continuous oxygen at home, a concentrator is a great option. However, if you need a portable solution or an emergency backup, an oxygen tank may be the better choice.
Always consult your healthcare professional before making a decision to ensure you receive the right oxygen therapy for your condition.
Pls check our oxygen concentrator and tank range and rental options.
On 14 February 2025, iElder.Asia had the privilege of sharing insights on Adaptive Equipment for Feeding during the AGEING & GERIATRIC REHABILITATION Course at the Pusat Kajian Penuaan Sihat & Kesejahteraan (H-CARE), Faculty of Health Sciences, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. We extend...
On April 19, 2024, iElder and Managedcare, in collaboration with Seniors Aloud, hosted a dynamic afternoon tea event at iElder SS2 in Petaling Jaya. This event, focused on "Caring for Seniors Living Alone," aimed to address the challenges faced by...
Leave a comment